Immigrated to Indiana 1852.
By contrast, what is in absolutely no doubt at all is the following:
s/o John Peter Weiebacher and Catharina Muller.
A cousin of his Peter [Jacob] Weyerbacher was born the same year... 21 Mar 1803. There were in fact, two Peter Weyerbachers, both born about 1803 and both married to wives named Catharine, who were also both born in 1803. These "Peters" were, in fact, cousins.
........
Are these two Weyerbacher lines, with immigration separated by 100 years, related, and if so, how?
......
Interesting story here.
Their parents were John Peter Weiebacher and Catharina Muller.
"In 1860 his brother was accidentally shot on the farm by a hired hand.
This appears to be August "Weierbacher" 1842-1860 – See tombstone at
http://marshaswarrickweb.com/cemeteries/images/plainview/weierbacheraugust.jpg "

Church book of Achtelsbach (Attached to 10 June 1976 letter from W. Wolfgang Munzert to Warren W. Wirebach), (Translated from the German):
c) Church Book Achtelsbach; marriage Ellweiler 5 Dec 1826; Peter Weyerbacher, 23 years old; son of Peter Weyerbacher and Catharina Müller, Neubrücker Mill;
Catharina Elisabetha Immig, 23 years old, daughter of Phillip Peter Immig and (der +) Elisabetha Gerhard, field people in Enkirch (a municipality in Rhineland-Palatinate, western Germany)
........
1870 Census shows [blurry/faded] John F Wierbacher and Catharine Wierbacher
Name John F Wierbacher
Age in 1870 67
Birth Date abt 1803
Birthplace Oldenburg
Dwelling Number 116
Home in 1870 Boonville, Warrick, Indiana
Occupation No Occupation
Father of Foreign Birth Yes
Mother of Foreign Birth Yes
Male Citizen Over 21 Yes
Personal Estate Value 100
Real Estate Value 30000
Inferred Spouse Catharine Wierbacher
......